Time to Defend Jeremy Bowen!

The BBC Trust has attacked the corporation’s Middle East editor Jeremy Bowen:

The BBC Trust yesterday called into question the corporation’s reporting of the most sensitive news story of modern times, publishing findings that the BBC Middle East editor, Jeremy Bowen, had breached guidelines on accuracy and impartiality. The ruling will be seized upon by campaigners who claim that BBC News is prejudiced against Israel in its coverage of the Middle East.

But the decision to censure Bowen caused anger within the BBC, with some alleging that the trust, which oversees the corporation, was undermining the credibility of its news.

Bowen was censured for a piece which he wrote for the BBC website last June under the headline “Six days that changed the Middle East”, attempting to give context to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict by analysing the events of the 1967 Six Day War. The Middle East editor referred to “Zionism’s innate instinct to push out the frontier”. He wrote that Israel showed a “defiance of everyone’s interpretation of international law except its own” and that its generals felt that they were dealing with “unfinished business”, left over from the 1948 War of Independence.

The committee ruled that Bowen’s reporting partially breached the BBC’s rules on accuracy and impartiality.

“Readers might come away from the article thinking that the interpretation offered was the only sensible view of the war,” it said. “It was not necessary for equal space to be given to the other arguments, but … the existence of alternative theses should have been more clearly signposted.”

A spokesman for BBC News said action would be taken to amend the website article but Bowen would not face any disciplinary measures.

Spineless, utterly spineless, and it follows on directly from their equally craven refusal to broadcast the DEC Emergency appeal for Gaza. Apparently they felt that broadcasting the appeal would have equally breached their rules on impartiality. Excuse me, how exactly? I thought the BBC’s ultimate responsibility was to report the news. Isn’t this nonsense about impartiality at all costs and under all circumstances what’s got American news into the catastrophic state it’s in now? At times like this I’m reminded of the quote from ‘Good Night and Good Luck’, denying that on every story there are two equal and logical sides to an argument. This is one of those stories. Robert Fisk is more outspoken in his condemnation:

The BBC Trust’s report on Jeremy Bowen’s dispatches from the Middle East is pusillanimous, cowardly, outrageous, factually wrong and ethically dishonest.

The trust – how I love that word which so dishonours everything about the BBC – has collapsed, in the most shameful way, against the usual Israeli lobbyists who have claimed – against all the facts – that Bowen was wrong to tell the truth.

The BBC’s preposterous committee claims that Bowen’s article “breached the rules [sic] on impartiality” because “readers might come away from the article thinking that the interpretation offered was the only sensible view of the war”.

Well, yes of course. Because I suppose the BBC believes that Israel’s claim to own land which in fact belongs to other people is another “sensible” view of the war. The BBC Trust – and I now find this word nauseous each time I tap it on my laptop – says that Bowen didn’t give evidence to prove the Jewish settlement at Har Homa was illegal. But the US authorities said so, right from the start. Our own late foreign secretary, Robin Cook – under screamed abuse from Zionists when he visited the settlement– said the same thing. The fact that the BBC Trust uses the Hebrew name for Har Homa – not the original Arab name, Jebel Abu Ghoneim – shows just how far it is now a mouthpiece for the Israeli lobby which so diligently abused Bowen.

In all honesty the BBC is becoming a watchword for bias and propaganda, be it recently referring to the arrest of environmental protesters as a ‘foiled plot’, trying to rewrite history to suggest Ian Tomlinson was merely shoved and not hit, and then this. If I as a consumer of news am sick to death of this, I can’t imagine how fed up genuinely talented journalists like Bowen must feel. Something is deeply wrong with the BBC; I’d be interested to hear if people think it was so pre-Hutton or whether this current problem is down to managerial spinelessness post-Hutton.


6 responses to “Time to Defend Jeremy Bowen!

  1. I see two sides to this.

    Firstly, Bowen didn’t report the facts or speak the truth. He presented his personal opinions and rendered his judgment of Israel. That’s not news; that’s Islamist anti-Semite propaganda.

    Secondly, you’re actually right about the underlying problem of requiring the alternative viewpoint to be “signposted” in a news report. Down that road lays a great evil.

    What clouds this particular issue though is the combination of these two points. Since much of what Bowen wrote was OpEd as opposed to news – though it was carefully disguised as such – it makes sense to require a counterpoint.

    Unfortunately that is a dangerous thing since the government – or special interest groups – could easily start demanding that of all reporting ala the US’ defunct-but-rising-again “Fairness Act.”

  2. yeah he reporter is obviously stating his feelings and opinion rather than just the facts. You pay for the facts, the opinion is just yellow journalism.

  3. I reckon it’s got worse since Hutton, but the pro-Israel bias definitely precedes the Hutton enquiry. The BBC’s previous middle east editor was moved to Johannesburg because the Israelis didn’t like her. I think what is interesting is that despite the bias the public is way ahead of the BBC – hence the uproar over the Gaza appeal.

  4. Just to say that I have always found Bowen’s reporting from the middle east very honest and impartial. It is regretable that in the UK we are unable to report the truth about the appalling treatment of Palestinians by the State of Israel which has lost what little humanity it ever had

  5. Of course this wont help much, the bbc will still be the leading force in the west in posioning peoples minds and showing them one sided news, years of expirience at this. No wonder so many people in GB hate Israel.

  6. Is there a limit of Zionist power over the world at this point? It looks like nobody, who tries to raise the issue of Israel’s occupation and ethnic cleansing, can get away with it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s